Everything Wrong With The Greatest Showman

Paylaş
Ekle

YORUMLAR • 14 618

  • Nicky Thepro
    Nicky Thepro 8 dakika önce

    I love how people take cinema sins seriously

  • Paw In Snow
    Paw In Snow Saatler önce

    Mistake: 9:11 how could she sing at normal speed when the rest of the world is in slow-mo?? No one ever told me she was the Flash.

  • Bright Moon
    Bright Moon 2 saatler önce

    Sin 21: The time the movie was set in, there were obvious differences between poor and rich. Also, Charity's father did not approve of Barnum.

  • Manubibi Walsh
    Manubibi Walsh 4 saatler önce

    Everything Wrong With Everything Wrong With The Greatest Showman:
    I have a few problems with this movie's plot but are you really gonna nitpick stuff like the dabbing and shit? Have you ever seen a musical? Also, have you ever watched other filmed musicals, like Moulin Rouge? Because honestly all stories and movies filmed like this have a lot of unlikely details (like, modern lighting during a choreographed song, how unlikely! Do you also bitch about theatres having light tricks during shows?) but the point was never realism, otherwise they would've started out this movie with all the billions things PT Barnum got involved with before starting his circus (which only happened when he was past his 60s). What next, are you gonna object that a musical has songs meant to narrate plot points which obviously doesn't happen in real life?

    The first thing you said that's actually relevant is how first he told the short guy that they were gonna laugh at him anyway and then that they were gonna respect him. I actually came here to hear about stuff like this, not... the choreografy being unlikely or whatever. You don't say?
    Also, how are you going to say that him championing a singer is a mistake because it means he lost sight of his original vision when THAT IS AN OPEN PLOT POINT AND THE WHOLE REASON EVERYTHING GOES TO SHIT LATER? Like, that's the whole reason conflict arises between him and his wife, it's the whole reason the "freaks" feel alienated from him later on, that's literally part of the story! It's specifically /intended/ for him to lose sight of his original vision.
    Also your social commentary was pretty much on point and yes, the character and real life counterpart of PT Barnum are real jerks but yo, you lost me when you were like "why am I supposed to feel pity for a white guy who was too poor to afford bread and why should I feel pity that he was socially shunned?" and I'm sitting here like, are you actually a sociopath? I mean, since when has poverty cared for someone's skin color? Yeah, I do bet black people had it worse back then as they do now, but financial struggle and social rejection hurt for everyone regardless of what color their skin is, and I know for a fact that some poor people will grow up wanting some kind of social redemption because, guess what? I have this happening in my own family. What's this bullshit? You sound like a middle-upper class white tumblr pseudo-feminist trying to get woke points with the other tumblrinas' crowd.
    "I don't know who to call racist and bigoted in this movie" pretty much everyone? Like, as you already stated, it sounds actually unbelievable to have Philip championing civil rights in the 18whatevers and then you're asking where are the non-racist characters? Pick one. Also, at the time abolitionists actually existed and white people who didn't see black people are inferior existed, and they've been existing since the US' declaration of independence, and earlier than that even because, guess what? Not everyone living in a certain context is the same, otherwise we wouldn't have had social progress at all, ever. And I'm pretty sure interracial relationships were very much a thing even before this movie's timeframe. Maybe they weren't accepted and were looked down on, but they were real, so your earlier objection to Zendaya and Zac Efron's characters being in a relationship openly seems very odd.
    Your objection about how no circus in history would've been big enough for the final number is... objectionable. I did some amount of research and read that at some point PT Barnum put on a huge circus that gave work to over a thousand people and that the circus was proper huge, so those shots in the ending don't actually seem to be that much of a stretch. But other than this, again, this movie's choreography stand on grandeur and a big glaringly obvious and overstated theme of this movie is awe and how to make people be in awe. Thematically, everything in The Greatest Show's and its reprise, going from the lighting to the composing to the choreographies are absolutely on point because they actually make viewers be in awe (maybe not you, but a lot of people were amazed by the first and last musical scenes, so if anything they succeeded and to succeed they needed to feel and look big.)
    So anyway, this movie definitely does its share of sinning, but all of it boils down to plot holes and incongruences that I'm actually pretty irked by, because everything else had potential and especially the musical number were crafted with a lot of care.
    A lot of your objections about historical inaccuracies are either flat out wrong which shows you yourself didn't do much research (the historical details you pointed out are, guess what, entirely pointless and unimportant to the story) and just leaned into the "let's just shit on a movie because the youtube audience for some reason LOVES it when things are ripped apart, who cares for at least being actually accurate?", and your criticism of the movie boils down to "I didn't bother researching anything about it because if I did I would've realized pretty much nothing in the movie is meant to be historically or factually accurate and it's more of an excuse to tell a story about acceptance, awe and dreams that could've been told using literally any other central character but for some reason they chose the first big enterpreneur in history and one of the earliest pop culture (meaning pop culture as we know it) icons". This criticism is sloppy and I'm criticizing it because I, just like you, love low hanging fruit.
    For a channel entirely devoted to picking movies apart, your job seems to be entirely about bringing up pointless things that are actually part of the genre and even passing as mistakes things that are purposefully MEANT to be in a certain story and actually be the source of conflict in the story, which is how stories are built, when you literally could've criticized anything in the story, like how pretty much all conflict is solved with 5 or 6 lines of dialogue if not... no dialogue at all and no shows of repentance, isn't that what's actually unrealistic and pretty unacceptable for a professionally-written story?
    This is bad criticism and you should feel bad.
    PS: By the way, "a million dreams is all it's gonna take" is grammatically correct. The subject of the sentence is "a million dreams". Your grammar objections are just as disastrous as your analytic skills.

  • Swordbird98
    Swordbird98 5 saatler önce

    you missed the sin of the elephants being too big and them slightly changing in size each scene

  • AndyTR8591
    AndyTR8591 8 saatler önce

    This video was stupid for so many reasons

  • Casey Wolfe
    Casey Wolfe 8 saatler önce

    Annnd now I need a Music Man remake with Jackman as Henry Hill. Thanks.

  • epicgamer16 xx
    epicgamer16 xx 11 saatler önce

    The funeral and bread stealing couldn't be in the same day because in the funeral it was winter . It's called a montage bro

  • Limey Boye
    Limey Boye 11 saatler önce

    It's good. I....really love the music.

  • Mattaku Bodimasen
    Mattaku Bodimasen 13 saatler önce

    The movie itself wasn't especially good or anything. The plot was rather unrealistic and naive kind-of. There are a lot of potential things the movie throw out but never actually used or explored. Many things don't exactly add up or make sense.
    Musical-wise, this was absolutely brilliant. The music and mood made you feel like you were part of the story itself and motivates you. It made me feel so imaginative and inspired.
    But I think the important thing to keep in mind is that this movie was made primarily for the musical, so the plot quality is understandable. Though you must admit that the songs were amazing.

  • madra uchiha
    madra uchiha 13 saatler önce

    barnum owned a slaver killed six whales and sowed a dead monkey to a fish to trick people into beleving it was a mermaid

  • Fanofmoststuff 15
    Fanofmoststuff 15 13 saatler önce

    It’s a movie and nothing is perfect

  • Megan Cunningham
    Megan Cunningham 14 saatler önce

    i'm triggered

  • Cat Claws
    Cat Claws 15 saatler önce

    I know this stuff is how you get money and I don't want you to stop... I hope you CAN enjoy movies.

  • Wartime Productions
    Wartime Productions 16 saatler önce

    I bloody hate “this is me” like it is so overplayed in England



    PT Barnum is still a racist slur put into a human body

  • Mash my face in your face
    Mash my face in your face 17 saatler önce

    *Theres nothing wrong with it*

  • J Δ Y •
    J Δ Y • 18 saatler önce

    not gonna lie I actually really loved this movie. and I’m hoping for a sequel at some point

  • Laina Mattox
    Laina Mattox 18 saatler önce

    If you're going to be a smart ass at least get your facts right

  • Sam Hatts
    Sam Hatts 18 saatler önce

    I have a technological sin, the singer Barnum gets sings quietly that know one would ever hear

  • Blah
    Blah 19 saatler önce

    The genius of this movie is that it’s designed like PT Barnum made it.

  • Lilyanna Jacobs 'Night terror'

    10:28. That type of force would of jerked her arm out of socket. Or at least ripped muscles in her shoulder, if not took her arm off completely.

  • ghostassasin81
    ghostassasin81 21 saatler önce

    Now I wanna see hugh jackman play in the music man

  • 0riginal _Panda_Child

    Tattooed colonel mustard

  • Brendan Ziegler
    Brendan Ziegler Gün önce

    That browns roast is straight fire!

  • Erin Ryan
    Erin Ryan Gün önce

    200 shut the fuck ups

  • Mimi Girl
    Mimi Girl Gün önce +1

    Cinema sins is the friend that doesn’t stop talking through films.

    • I only ship jessie and james cough cough
      I only ship jessie and james cough cough 3 saatler önce

      +Manubibi Walsh People who think their funny annoy the hell out of me, basically everyone in my class annoys me...

    • Manubibi Walsh
      Manubibi Walsh 3 saatler önce +1

      Not even a friend, they're the obnoxious, obviously insecure stranger that just won't shut the fuck up because they think they're funny.

  • Nearly Witches
    Nearly Witches Gün önce

    The biggest flaw is that Brendan Urie wasn’t in it.

  • meme trends dont live long

    Why are you so against Barnum? . I know he did some bad things but... Still

  • Antifearstrikes
    Antifearstrikes Gün önce

    I came prepared on this vid. I literally waited for me to prepare for all the mistakes!!!

  • lets explore the world

    2:19 r.i.p headphone users

  • Georgia Archdall
    Georgia Archdall Gün önce

    With the juggling one, if you are talented enough, or rehearsed enough, you can juggle anything without looking. The main strategy with juggling is not watch the things you are juggling

  • Anthony
    Anthony Gün önce +3

    In 5:56 does he mean Harold Hill instead of Henry Hill because Henry Hill was part of an Italian gang and was part of the biggest heist in American history while Harold Hill was a character in a musical in the 60s

  • MIKA COHEN
    MIKA COHEN Gün önce

    Shut the fuck up. what do you know about real dreams.. sad fuck

  • Jacob keyser
    Jacob keyser Gün önce

    I would see that music man

  • Li Rodj7
    Li Rodj7 Gün önce

    I know how "everyone" loves this film but he had his points and honestly i hated hugh jackmans charachter dont tell me some you didnt want to punch the twat when he closed the door of them

  • Xander DeLioncourt
    Xander DeLioncourt Gün önce

    After my wife nagged me for months to see this we finally sat down and watched it. By the end she was apologizing. I have a much larger list of what’s wrong with this movie.

  • Weeple Loves Sheep
    Weeple Loves Sheep Gün önce

    wow the comments of this video are the prime example of unforgiving musical people.

  • Lance Browning
    Lance Browning Gün önce

    You need to shut this channel down. You try SO HARD to come up with what you call "sins" that it's pathetic and embarrassing. Time to move on to something else.

  • Kwink0
    Kwink0 Gün önce

    Thank you for sinning this

  • AbysmolAbomination
    AbysmolAbomination Gün önce

    the tea is piping hot and i am LIVING for it

  • Jerry Mccormac
    Jerry Mccormac Gün önce

    Your a fucking asshole bitch

  • Hollyleaf81
    Hollyleaf81 Gün önce

    Another sine: THE FICKITY FRACTITY SONG THAT IS SUPOST TO BE OPRA IS NOT AT ALL OPRA! IT'S FUCKING POP

    • Hollyleaf81
      Hollyleaf81 Gün önce

      Also the actress wasn't even singing the dang song, it was voiced over

  • H K-Y
    H K-Y Gün önce +2

    Cirque de Foreplay
    And dies....

  • H K-Y
    H K-Y Gün önce

    9:08 Zendayas pose should've been a sin then😂

  • crybaby.jewels
    crybaby.jewels Gün önce

    Is there even a movie that is perfect for CinemaSins?

  • Stw482
    Stw482 Gün önce +1

    Oh fuck off man, I thought these were gonna be real reasons

  • WindowsXP
    WindowsXP Gün önce

    2:03 Holy Shit Jean Val Jean

  • jerome bacorro
    jerome bacorro 2 gün önce

    Fuck you dont ruin this movie for me me and my gf fucking cried goddamn

    • Jerry Mccormac
      Jerry Mccormac Gün önce

      I'm sorry for your girl friend he's a fuck asshole bitch

  • Albert Tedjo
    Albert Tedjo 2 gün önce

    WHAT MOVIE DO YOU LIKE????

  • GoShelbyGoYo
    GoShelbyGoYo 2 gün önce

    'PT's Bar & Num Num's.' Yes!

  • Arlene Aong
    Arlene Aong 2 gün önce

    MAKE A MOVIE THEN

  • Chen Wei Yeo
    Chen Wei Yeo 2 gün önce

    This channel must've had 0 subs

  • Lavender Davies
    Lavender Davies 2 gün önce

    NOTHING

  • Hailey Wideman
    Hailey Wideman 2 gün önce

    The very end!❤😂😂i love signs!

  • carypm
    carypm 2 gün önce

    2:22 the subject of the sentence is “a million” so “a million is” is the correct subject verb agreement

  • Ashlyn Archuleta
    Ashlyn Archuleta 2 gün önce

    I like watching your videos but I really hate you for this. This movie is beautiful and amazing and it's not a biography on P.T. Barnum! This movie is to entertain, not to inform. Also the music is amazing in this movie and it hurts me to see that you gave it so many sins so that's +1 dislike on this video.

  • Andrei Natanauan
    Andrei Natanauan 2 gün önce

    Fuck you

  • dara assassin
    dara assassin 2 gün önce +1

    I was gonna watch this because it was on tv last week but than I thought about the singing and dancing and zac efron I thought this will be another high school musical

    Oh yeah try not to mine my spelling

  • Makayli Mercer
    Makayli Mercer 2 gün önce

    Exsqueeze me?!?! I love this movie bit you have a point lol

  • Onyx Corvus
    Onyx Corvus 2 gün önce

    This is a movie about struggle, with absolutely no struggle in it. I fucking hated this movie.

  • Deyton Harney
    Deyton Harney 2 gün önce

    You have to explain why “everything wrong is wrong” well that’s just weak and The Greatest Showman is the best movie ever

  • Thydoomchanther NGAMD
    Thydoomchanther NGAMD 2 gün önce +3

    "19th century dabbing" Lmao

  • Joshua Connell
    Joshua Connell 2 gün önce

    its a fictional movie why do you have to make it about race and shit

  • epicfail
    epicfail 2 gün önce +1

    The cartoon statement can't work in the movie because it happens before cartoons

  • Yves Jordan Libante
    Yves Jordan Libante 3 gün önce

    The person who make this video is fucking idiot..
    Gurl its musical movie

  • Choosquared The God
    Choosquared The God 3 gün önce

    Henry hill?????? You do mean Harold hill correct?

  • William Forest-Hill
    William Forest-Hill 3 gün önce

    1:48 speak you yourself, dill hole

  • GamingWithEJ Estelon
    GamingWithEJ Estelon 3 gün önce

    This Is Greatest Showman Not Worst Showman

  • TheSonicFan101//TSF101
    TheSonicFan101//TSF101 3 gün önce

    Please, we just ENJOY the movie. This is a musical fiction(except for PT). Just please stop.

  • Shane Morris
    Shane Morris 3 gün önce

    It’s a musical you realize that right?

  • jørdyn grøve
    jørdyn grøve 3 gün önce

    its just a dumb movie

  • Elektra St. Thomas
    Elektra St. Thomas 3 gün önce

    *Oh look he invented the rave*

  • Darelle Arcilla
    Darelle Arcilla 3 gün önce

    You have no imagination for questioning everything...

  • James Inaren
    James Inaren 3 gün önce

    I feel like this movie has a very good theme and message. Not only does Barnum end up totally happy with nothing but his family, my favorite message, but it also puts across the point that anyone can be special. Whether you're a physical freak, a poor white guy, a rich white guy, or an extremely athletic black lady you can make an impact.

  • Little Karen
    Little Karen 3 gün önce

    i used to like watching these videos, but now i can't stand to watch them anymore. the only fact they really seem to bring up is that pt barnum was a jerk and racist, newsflash back then every white business man was. it just seems now this guy just watches a show long enough to make fun of it, doesn't even really watch it. & it doesn't even bring up the fact that philip's jacket completely half way thru the last song of the movie. which i don't think was a goof, i think they did that deliberately for symbolism.

  • Baneewii
    Baneewii 3 gün önce

    WARNING DO NOT READ THIS IF YOU GET OFFENDED EASILY


    i do not like this movie

  • cartoonbeeb
    cartoonbeeb 3 gün önce

    the amount of people trying to defend racism in the comments is hilarious

  • Jackson Holt
    Jackson Holt 3 gün önce

    11:05, the laugh gets me every time 😂😂

  • FireWing Phoenix
    FireWing Phoenix 3 gün önce

    Man. Why are people so butt hurt. Like the movie who cares. This guy is just doing his job

  • Alan Nights
    Alan Nights 3 gün önce

    2:20
    Why he didn't visit her ?
    Probably b/c no one would let him in the Academy for Girls :P

  • Kim van den Bosch
    Kim van den Bosch 3 gün önce

    "A million dreams is all its gonna take" is actually a correct sentence. I am aware that "dreams" is plural and "is" isn't but because it's not just "dreams" but "A million dreams", with emphasis on A, the subject has become singular. Works the same in Dutch grammar.

  • Aidin Brennan
    Aidin Brennan 3 gün önce

    This is fing hysterical!

  • Pam Latcham
    Pam Latcham 3 gün önce

    The best movie ever plus movies don't need a reson

  • Tim Aldred
    Tim Aldred 4 gün önce +1

    Hate much?

  • Baran Sh
    Baran Sh 4 gün önce

    ok this is a movie a BEAUTIFUL movie sooo stop doing this to such amaxing movies

  • AL-X BERLANGA
    AL-X BERLANGA 4 gün önce

    Straight out of Compton left out a whole bunch of stuff about dr.dre and easy e and was wildly praised, this movie has songs in it and its garbage. Really?

  • Savannah Bains
    Savannah Bains 4 gün önce +1

    Honestly you are just mad that you can’t make anything as good as the greatest showman so you try to make it look bad when it’s the best movie ever made.

  • MW3lover1473
    MW3lover1473 4 gün önce

    He missed a blooper. PT stole a loaf of bread. Hugh Jackman who plays PT also plays Jean Valjean who also stole a loaf of bread. Coincidence?

  • Owen Beatty
    Owen Beatty 4 gün önce

    Wow that browns joke hurt me

  • michael petersen
    michael petersen 4 gün önce

    This guy is an idiot. cinemaSins sucks. who cares what you think. We do not see you making it in the life ?
    You are just another TRclips looser with a opinion.

  • toasty Tortellinii
    toasty Tortellinii 4 gün önce

    Charity looks like legolas sometimes lmao

  • Ashley Gay
    Ashley Gay 4 gün önce

    Funny

  • James Weatherly
    James Weatherly 4 gün önce +2

    There are way to many songs

  • Meme Machine
    Meme Machine 4 gün önce

    As someone who loves history and being someone who hates when all the facts are given, it is quite clear that from the start, this movie is trying to be historically accurate, I honestly dislike the fact that you keep sinning it to just pad out your runtime.

  • Hatyja Ovekova
    Hatyja Ovekova 4 gün önce

    if you have no imagination then you wont like this musical because it is actually an amazing musical better that any other......

  • Suga Yoongi
    Suga Yoongi 4 gün önce

    THIS FILM AND THE SONG IN IT HAS HAD WAY TOO MUCH EXPOSURE no offence but i now hate it

  • Moomin girl
    Moomin girl 5 gün önce

    i'm fainting fainting fainting! hello i am suing the producer's of this movie

  • Jellytabby
    Jellytabby 5 gün önce

    He will never be satisfied. He will never be satisfiiiiiiied.
    Damn Angelica was right

  • KUNJ SHAH
    KUNJ SHAH 5 gün önce

    So much negativity...

  • Emma Lucente
    Emma Lucente 5 gün önce

    Should have also added a sin for the pointe shoes the daughter was wearing. At that point in history, pointe shoes had barely been invented and definitely didn’t look like that(the modern point shoe).