Everything Wrong With The Greatest Showman

  • katma 3 May 2018
  • This movie has sins, several just for trying to make it seem like P.T. Barnum was a super nice and swell guy. TLDR: he wasn't.
    Remember, no movie is without sin! Which movie's sins should we expose next?!
    Podcast: soundcloud.com/cinemasins
    Sins Video Playlist: trclips.com/video/wy-v4c4is-w/video.html
    Tweet us: twitter.com/cinemasins
    Reddit with us: reddit.com/r/cinemasins
    Tumble us: cinema-sins.tumblr.com
    Call us: 405-459-7466
    Jeremy's book: theablesbook.com Merch: teespring.com/stores/cinemasins-store
  • Film ve AnimasyonFilm ve Animasyon

YORUMLAR • 16 125

  • Dr.Oppai
    Dr.Oppai 15 dakika önce

    at this point he’s just sinning the movie for the littlest things. tsk they’re really not the same anymore dude. he literally added a sin for them having a big room, them saying “you better come see this”, etc. it’s fucking retarded. smh

  • Japie van Niekerk
    Japie van Niekerk 14 saatler önce

    11:03 Am I the only one questioning the fact that the rope is just there instead of going up because of the weight?

  • Stephen Sekhose
    Stephen Sekhose 18 saatler önce

    What you're saying is bull shit

  • Riley Jay
    Riley Jay 21 saatler önce

    This is my favorite Cinema sins episode 😂😂😂😂

  • Ethan Snoopy Cho
    Ethan Snoopy Cho 23 saatler önce


    JASMINE SMITH Gün önce

    If the movie did everything your way, then it wouldn’t even be the same plot!

    *Its a musical!*

  • Max !
    Max ! Gün önce

    Also, you forgot one. In the scene with the ropes and stuff the d00d (forgot his name) runs off stage before the whole catching physics thing and for only that shot the rope disappears completely

  • Fire_Blast 02
    Fire_Blast 02 Gün önce

    I feel angry for you calling them loosers

  • Cookin it up with Ebele

    when i went to go to the greatest showman I didnt know it was a musical because i hate musicals then it started i hated it

  • Zamiel Abyss GeEnna Dunamis

    Cinema sins get out of your comfort zone! Come on make a perfect version of the greatest showman !

  • The Lonely Dragon
    The Lonely Dragon 2 gün önce

    Look, I know your whole job is to basically curse out films, but this movie was amazing, and I think you just needed to upload a video to get some views

  • Avery Stirling
    Avery Stirling 2 gün önce +2

    5:56 he must be really happy that Hugh Jackman has actually signed on for the music Man.

  • Tundra ._.
    Tundra ._. 2 gün önce

    A Extremely Underrated Movie

  • Blessing Thinambo
    Blessing Thinambo 2 gün önce

    Really dude do you have to say there something wrong with every movie

  • JD Bond
    JD Bond 2 gün önce

    1:52 so kids can’t have friends!? Jeez! Also cartoons didn’t exist at the time.

  • Tyler Lim
    Tyler Lim 2 gün önce

    In my opinion this is one of the best movies ever made.

  • Glittergirl 123
    Glittergirl 123 2 gün önce

    There is actually nothing wrong with the greatest showman it’s an amazing movie with a great background story. You don’t just have to think about the negatives of everything you know so you may swell stop this channel now

  • Haydin Le
    Haydin Le 3 gün önce


  • Asha Marion
    Asha Marion 3 gün önce

    I was not really thinking I would like this movie but I ended up really liking it

    • Bo Reyes
      Bo Reyes 2 gün önce

      "I was not really thinking I would like it but I enden up liking it" cliche

  • handle me
    handle me 3 gün önce


  • Light Yagami
    Light Yagami 3 gün önce +5

    9:19 There, he removed a sin. Happy now?

  • Okidmaster 13
    Okidmaster 13 4 gün önce

    Hugh Jackman is going to be in The Music Man as Henry Hill on broadway!!! I can’t wait!!!

  • Bella Winchester
    Bella Winchester 4 gün önce +1

    Another sin: how did Philip just somehow someway learn how to do trapeze perfectly with no practice

  • Eleanors Creation Vacation

    Am I the only one who keeps watching this like 5 times each day?😳

  • Jujinator 101
    Jujinator 101 4 gün önce +1

    I’d just like to point out: you are correct. Hugh Jackman would make a perfect Harold Hill. AND HE IS.

  • Sonjia Menches
    Sonjia Menches 4 gün önce


  • Mac K
    Mac K 4 gün önce +1

    Why don’t you F******stop I love this movie

  • Mac K
    Mac K 4 gün önce +1

    F*** you ok there may be some flaws in this movie but the greatest showman is a FANTASTIC movie plus the kids names are Hellen and Caroline 🙄🙄🙄🙄

  • 2ndAmendmentGlock
    2ndAmendmentGlock 4 gün önce

    Barnum in the movie gave his business to zac because they were partners...not because he was a fellow "white racist". Zac actually married the black acrobat woman in the movie which completely destroys that "sin" that you fabricated.
    You do realize only 1.4% of americans (blacks included) owned slaves. On top of that being a slave didn't mean you were sub human, it just meant you were on the bottom level of the social classes. Also, 1860's rich white people actually freed the slaves....so clearly a majority weren't racist either. There are also many accounts of slaves loving their masters and treating each other as family, I do not know what Barnum's case was but if you are calling him a racist just because he owned a slave then you do not understand the social structure and history of slavery in the past.

  • Kendy Died
    Kendy Died 4 gün önce

    Yo if they couldn't have gotten a bearded lady they could've gotten a bearded trans lady. There are good trans actors and singers out there that could've really used this role bc hollywood is transphobic. But instead they got a non bearded chick and put her through hours of makeup for that terrible beard.

  • VoZe B
    VoZe B 5 gün önce

    I was sure you would sin the movie for the animal abuse or how in the last scene the elephant probably died of hypothermia

  • Ashlynn Gibbons
    Ashlynn Gibbons 5 gün önce

    At 12:40 the sentence has all C's besides one or two

  • Arch Er
    Arch Er 5 gün önce

    i would like to point out that it’s just been released that Hugh Jackman is now gonna be playing the Music Man on Broadway. this is a full circle. one sin removed.

  • The Castle2000
    The Castle2000 5 gün önce

    Why couldn't you just stop to try to ruine this beautiful movie thanks for nothing

  • CookieGamer :3
    CookieGamer :3 5 gün önce

    I didn’t really like this movie too much, and I don’t know why. The bartender was my favorite character. Everyone thought it was the best. 。゚(゚´ω`゚)゚。

  • Malachi Schauer
    Malachi Schauer 6 gün önce +1

    10:31. I'm surprised he didn't comment on the hoop appearing randomly.

  • Saffiredragon X3
    Saffiredragon X3 6 gün önce

    14:29 112 MAN THAT'S TRIGGERING (i wish it was 111)

  • Ella Bella
    Ella Bella 6 gün önce

    I think I can win cinemacins

    Didn't the slave trade and in 1833 when it was made illegal so how was pt barnam look down upon in his youth because his dad couldn't afford slaves

  • ThePsychoMailman ThatStoleMyBody

    The reasons I did not enjoy the Greatest Showman.
    1.The unrealistic representation of P.T Barnum. I can't even get this there were just so many things.
    2.The completely wrong representation of the Swedish nightingale. Come on she was was never known for her beauty just her voice.
    3. Never enough made me sick. The Swedish nightingale was an opera singer. Is it to much to ask that they even keep the character close to what happened? A generic pop/contemporary song is very different than an opera.
    4.There was wayyyyyy to much artistic license taken with this movie. I do understand wanting to mix genres and make something new but to me it just made the movie feel like someone took 50 different puzzles and then tried to make a picture with them, it just felt so mismatched.
    5. the movie just jumps around it feel more like someone just wrote a bunch of music then someone said "Hey I know lets make a movie with that".
    6.(I'm not done yet) Once again as far as artistic liberties go They just went to far. The movie is so historically inaccurate it makes my head hurt.
    7. The pacing, The movie just jumps around and It's hard to tell what passage of time is happening between shots. Like, it could be two days or six months and you wouldn't know.

  • Baylee Carter
    Baylee Carter 6 gün önce

    I understand the more than friend thing at elementary age but........um me and my best friend is dating 😂

  • Michael Sali
    Michael Sali 6 gün önce

    Everything's wrong with The greatest showman:

  • Michael Sali
    Michael Sali 6 gün önce

    Ahh fuck off! You hater of TGS!

  • Nick Nguyen
    Nick Nguyen 6 gün önce

    i haven't seen this movie yet, but i already know you are a douche after 15 sec, time to see honest trailer...

  • Br Ec
    Br Ec 6 gün önce +3

    I miss the old Cinema Sins where they actually criticized the ACTUAL movie points/plot holes and not historical accuracy or things that are obviously meant for creativity.

  • Ahappyfrown321
    Ahappyfrown321 6 gün önce

    Meh, I still enjoyed this movie. And I HATE musicals.

  • Ahappyfrown321
    Ahappyfrown321 6 gün önce


  • Chris Meeker
    Chris Meeker 7 gün önce

    Haha - she'll tire of of your life of having nothing - "tell that to Cleveland Browns fans!" Milk spewed from my nose...

  • LunarChibi
    LunarChibi 7 gün önce

    So just because he is white it means he can't know what it means to struggle? Poor is poor, it doesn't matter what skin tone you are.

  • Wrubies
    Wrubies 7 gün önce

    I personally didn't love this movie or musical, bad story imo and just boring in general. What you guys think?

  • I’m_A_Weirdo_That_Likes_Anime_And_Gay_Shit _

    When I saw this movie all I could think is, ‘Can this get anymore cliché?’

  • Lizluzz
    Lizluzz 7 gün önce

    MY OPINION (DONT GET MAD): Hate this movie, so, so much. It’s fucking annoying and the story is kinda cliche (prohibited love, chasing dreams) and the scenes are kinda random (like when that famous woman just showed up out of nowhere?).

    Wanna reply to this comment, just smashing the keyboard, do so. Idc, it’s my opinion. FREEDOM OF SPEECH

  • Amy Mckeown
    Amy Mckeown 7 gün önce

    "real life o'hare from the lorax" 😂

  • Mankest_of_Demes
    Mankest_of_Demes 7 gün önce

    I don’t even know how you could even make a video of everything wrong about The Greatest Showman. It was such a great movie! In my opinion, I thought it was the best movie of 2017.

  • Plague terrace
    Plague terrace 7 gün önce

    Plz dont

  • isiex rias
    isiex rias 7 gün önce

    Everything wrong with your vid is you son of bitch

  • Grammar Police
    Grammar Police 7 gün önce

    *sees other videos*
    *me: subscribes*
    *sees this*
    *me: unsubscribes and sends a nuke*

  • ReJ Sallentes
    ReJ Sallentes 8 gün önce

    haha...it says "That we can design" it doesn't say "i have designed"
    btw that was number 12

  • ReJ Sallentes
    ReJ Sallentes 8 gün önce

    everything wrong with this movie:
    ......lol nothing

  • Pink and Proud
    Pink and Proud 8 gün önce

    It’s gonna be one hell of a movie when cinema sins enjoys it

  • SoulsXandXStars -Soul-
    SoulsXandXStars -Soul- 8 gün önce

    Dude. Stop trying. I’d tell you most of the answers to your questions but I’m too lazy to type it all.

  • Jane the killer
    Jane the killer 8 gün önce

    *nothing is wrong with this movie*
    *but I still love u*

  • freaky sword
    freaky sword 8 gün önce

    I personally like the movie

  • Matthew Shepherd
    Matthew Shepherd 8 gün önce +1

    You deserve a reward for being able to make 15 minutes of hate for a movie that I loved more than the cold side of the pillow.
    P.S. you gotta love the singing though right?

    • Sona the Cloud
      Sona the Cloud 7 gün önce +1

      Ok your comment is amazing and all but I love that you used “the cold side of a pillow” as the good comparison cause that’s, like, one of the best things you can get

  • Whale Games
    Whale Games 8 gün önce

    5:56 who the hell is Henry Hill? It's Harold Hill

  • Gweedy_L C-137
    Gweedy_L C-137 8 gün önce

    Make a girl laugh: Life long love
    *SNEAK 100*

  • Penelope Jennings
    Penelope Jennings 8 gün önce

    the browns joke has aged incredibly well

  • The Evie Show
    The Evie Show 8 gün önce


  • RadioactiveRoses
    RadioactiveRoses 8 gün önce

    I love how everyone is sticking up for this movie because it's full of pretty singing people, when it's about as historically accurate as Disney's Pocahontas.
    It's fine if you like it. It's pretty and the songs are nice. But let's not pretend it's anything more than that folks.

  • Tyranid Sid
    Tyranid Sid 9 gün önce

    The greatest showman is over rated.

  • ꧁༺햄찌모찌귀요미༻꧂

    jeez..it's just a movie...

  • Adrian Cheifetz-Broca
    Adrian Cheifetz-Broca 9 gün önce

    Hey did you here about how High Jackman is going to be Harold Hill in the Music Man remake.

  • Crystal Art
    Crystal Art 9 gün önce

    I hate this that is my favorite movie

  • keewf fbywrhathrrd
    keewf fbywrhathrrd 9 gün önce +1

    In the 2 seconds before the daughters simultaneously hammer, they are both using their right hands to hammer.

  • michael davis
    michael davis 9 gün önce

    It's a film not a documentary

  • Kaley
    Kaley 9 gün önce +1


  • Artbug
    Artbug 9 gün önce +1

    this channel has gone downhill because its just another cis white male self hating propaganda channel. I cant believe I just wasted my time watching this video... this was in my recommend, but Im gonna find out a way to block this junk channel completely

  • Artbug
    Artbug 9 gün önce +12

    You're giving sins to a child's imagination for not being realistic?
    I watched you guys for years and it really seems like you've lost the groove/magic you used to have making these videos

    • JD Bond
      JD Bond 2 gün önce

      Artbug yes! exactly!!!

  • Peri Flores
    Peri Flores 9 gün önce

    5:53 And now he IS Harold Hill

  • wolfhawk/ethan clark
    wolfhawk/ethan clark 9 gün önce +1

    U r ruining the movie 4 everyone

  • clark daniel sisto
    clark daniel sisto 9 gün önce

    10:38 was a good one

  • Enakronizum
    Enakronizum 9 gün önce +12

    I will solely thank Cinema Sins and only Cinema Sins for Hugh Jackman's Broadway rendition of Music Man. Thank you Cinema Sins, thank you

  • Kat Sparkle-Dust
    Kat Sparkle-Dust 9 gün önce

    Actually do some research, or a least watch the movie before making a video like this.
    Also, if you anything about plot and modern day filming, I think you could figure out why a few things happened. Like the lighting, and the kiss.

  • Darth Vader
    Darth Vader 10 gün önce

    I'm sorry but
    This is the greatest show it is a work of art I have to dislike it

  • 8Pastel Planet8
    8Pastel Planet8 10 gün önce

    Watching the movie for the first time and seeing this scene ( 10:50 ) gave me some serious anxiety.

  • Emily Miles
    Emily Miles 10 gün önce +2

    Just need to pop an 'is' in the title. Everything IS wrong with The Greatest Showman.

  • diogo lourenco
    diogo lourenco 10 gün önce

    Most overrated movie of 2017

  • Dragon queen
    Dragon queen 10 gün önce +4

    "I close my eyes and I can see... ''
    I don't think that's how that works but OK...

  • James Playsz
    James Playsz 10 gün önce

    Why did you did it

  • I. J. Boeck.
    I. J. Boeck. 11 gün önce +2

    This movie is the best. How dare you speak against it. That's a sin.

  • Dragon Hybrid Purple Jayden
    Dragon Hybrid Purple Jayden 11 gün önce +1

    THERE IS NOTHING WORNG WITH THE GREATEST SHOWMAN (also ur comments r gunna be a war zone saying wether not something is wrong with greatest showman)

    • JediBerry
      JediBerry 9 gün önce

      Dragon Hybrid Purple Jayden are you in third grade. I mean seriously it’s not even your opinion that offends me it’s just your grammar

  • weirdo world1813
    weirdo world1813 11 gün önce +1


    • JediBerry
      JediBerry 9 gün önce

      I understand liking movies but you have to understand what you like isn’t what everyone likes

    • John
      John 10 gün önce

      weirdo world1813 HUGE AGREE!

  • Frida Kristianne Haugen Varskog

    Shit my friend's gonna fuckin flip

  • Steven Kelly
    Steven Kelly 11 gün önce +1

    The fact that his video is even a thing is a sin, there is nothing wrong with this film in the slightest for me.

  • catyeyes87
    catyeyes87 11 gün önce +3

    Good news! Hugh Jackman is going to be in The Music Man on Broadway!

  • fittutube
    fittutube 11 gün önce

    Great movie. And Im a cynical, unromantic, tired of life kind of guy.

  • Stephen Reynolds Ilioes
    Stephen Reynolds Ilioes 11 gün önce

    Hush...let me enjoy the movie..but..damn

  • Nick Beaudry
    Nick Beaudry 12 gün önce

    Should've added 10 Sins for Hugh Jackman's haircut !

  • Nicaise Onyike
    Nicaise Onyike 12 gün önce +1

    Hater true hater why cant you just enjoy the movie and just shut your yap.

  • Mr bendy and Gabe the doge

    *sees this*
    Oh so now there making stupid comments about a really good movie well now I can say fuck you cimsins

  • the 3 rat kids
    the 3 rat kids 12 gün önce +1

    To be honest you are just hating on the best show